The economics of empty trips
School authors:
author photo
Ricardo Giesen
author photo
Luis Ignacio Rizzi
External authors:
  • Dario Farren ( Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile )
Abstract:

Empty trucks have a significant impact on the efficiency and sustainability of logistics operations, accounting for a substantial portion of the intercity truck flow, ranging from 15% to 40%. While some of these empty trips can be attributed to load imbalances, it is common to observe the flow of empty trucks in both directions of a route. This paper introduces a microeconomic model aimed at providing a deeper understanding of the flow of empty vehicles beyond load imbalances and its implications for freight flows, transport prices, and the number of carriers in the free-entry equilibrium. Our approach captures shippers' preferences when selecting carriers within a system comprising two locations with cargo flow in both directions. The model incorporates price competition among carriers and the production of differentiated services, as shippers perceive carriers' services in a heterogeneous manner. Given that carriers lack knowledge of shippers' preferences, these are represented using a random utility model. The model enables the determination and comparison of equilibrium conditions with the social optimum. The results show that: (1) The transportation of goods results in not only empty vehicles due to imbalanced loads but also a natural occurrence of empty vehicles due to the stochastic demand patterns. (2) When a new carrier enters the market, it contributes to the negative impact of empty vehicles through the business stealing effect. (3) Empty trips disrupt the balance of prices and carriers, creating a gap between the free-entry equilibrium and the socially optimal values. (4) By coordinating carriers' operations, the flow of empty vehicles due to the business stealing effect can be minimized, moving the system towards the socially optimal outcome.

UT WOS:001251507200001
Number of Citations
Type
Pages
ISSUE
Volume 39
Month of Publication SEP
Year of Publication 2024
DOI https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecotra.2024.100361
ISSN
ISBN
200 @ app_publication_show
HTTP status 200 OK
Route name app_publication_show
Has session no
Stateless Check no
Time 53 ms
Total time 53 ms
Initialization time 8 ms
Memory 6.0 MiB
Peak memory usage 6.0 MiB
PHP memory limit 1024 MiB
Logger 2
Errors 0
Warnings 0
Deprecations 2
Security n/a
Authenticated No
Firewall name main
Twig 18 ms
Render Time 18 ms
Template Calls 6
Block Calls 5
Macro Calls 0
9 in 5.23 ms
Database Queries 9
Different statements 7
Query time 5.23 ms
Invalid entities 0
Second Level Cache disabled
7.1.10
Profiler token 69f987
Environment dev
Debug enabled
PHP version 8.3.22   View phpinfo()
PHP Extensions Xdebug ✗ APCu ✗ OPcache ✓
PHP SAPI fpm-fcgi